Key points
- Do not cancel the old policy until the new one is confirmed in writing, with a start date and time.
- Make your uninsured motorist choice again; the statute's carry-over language refers to the same insurer (56-7-1201).
- Tennessee accepts proof of insurance on paper or on a phone (55-12-139).
- If you have a car loan or lease, tell your lender about the new insurer (TN Revenue, NAIC).

Mid-South Insurance Agency is a family-owned independent agency in Hendersonville that helps drivers in Sumner, Wilson and Davidson counties compare auto insurance. This guide lays out, in order, the steps for moving from one insurer to another, whatever the reason for the move.
The order that avoids a gap
A gap means a stretch of days when no policy is in force on a car. It usually happens when the old policy is canceled before the new one starts, or when an effective date is misread. Tennessee drivers must be able to show proof of insurance whenever an officer asks, and failing to show it is a Class C misdemeanor with a fine of up to $300 (Tenn. Code Ann. 55-12-139).
The order below keeps one policy in force at every moment. The steps apply whatever the reason for the move: a renewal that changed, a life event, a move, a new car or simply wanting to compare options.
- Find your current policy's renewal or expiration date and its declarations page.
- Request quotes using the same drivers, vehicles and coverages so you can compare like with like.
- Choose the new policy and its effective date and time. Ask the insurer to confirm in writing that coverage is in force from that moment; coverage begins only when the insurer confirms it.
- Download the new ID cards and put a copy on your phone.
- Only after that, contact your current insurer or agent to cancel, and ask for the cancellation date in writing.
- Tell your lender or leasing company, if you have one, who the new insurer is.
Compare the same things
The NAIC's national shopping guide suggests writing down each company's coverages and deductibles side by side so you are comparing the same policy. Compare liability limits, uninsured and underinsured motorist limits, deductibles for collision and comprehensive, and any optional items such as rental reimbursement or towing.
Because there is no such thing as a "full coverage" policy, as the NAIC puts it, ask each insurer to name the coverages; our guide on what "full coverage" means explains why. Many carriers offer multi-policy and safe-driver discounts, and we check which ones you may qualify for.
Re-making your uninsured motorist choice
Tennessee includes uninsured motorist coverage in an auto liability policy at limits equal to the bodily injury limits, and a named insured may reject it or choose lower limits in writing (Tenn. Code Ann. 56-7-1201). The statute's carry-over language says a rejection does not have to be repeated at renewal, reinstatement or replacement of a policy previously issued by the same insurer. It also says that when a new application is submitted, the section applies in the same manner as for a new policy.
A policy from a different insurer is a new policy, so plan on making the UM choice again, in writing, on the new application. Read the form before you sign it. Our guide on uninsured drivers in Tennessee explains the options.
Proof of insurance during the change
Tennessee accepts a declarations page, binder or insurance card in paper or electronic form, including an image on a cellular phone. Keep both the old card and the new card until the old policy ends and the new policy has started. If you are stopped, show the one that is in force.
The statute provides that a first violation for failing to show proof is dismissed if the court is satisfied that coverage was in effect. That is a reason to keep the paperwork in one folder, not a reason to cut it close.
Lenders, leases and other policies
The Tennessee Department of Revenue notes that if you have a car loan or lease, your lender may require collision and comprehensive coverage. The NAIC says a lender typically requires them until the loan is paid off. Send the new declarations page to the lender when your new policy starts.
If you bundle auto with a home, renters or umbrella policy, ask how moving one policy changes the others. We can quote home insurance and personal umbrella insurance together with your auto.
Starting the conversation
You do not have to tell us why you are looking. Bring your current declarations page, the list of drivers and vehicles, and your lender's insurance requirements if any. We will ask for a quote from the carriers we work with and go over the options and effective dates with you. Call 615-824-9009 or request a quote.
Sources (4)
- Tennessee Code (FindLaw): Tenn. Code Ann. 56-7-1201 (uninsured motorist coverage) (checked November 2026)
- Tennessee Code (FindLaw): Tenn. Code Ann. 55-12-139 (proof of financial responsibility) (checked November 2026)
- Nebraska Department of Insurance: Auto insurance shopping guide (PDF) (checked November 2026)
- Tennessee Dept. of Revenue: Drive Insured Tennessee: Why you should have insurance (checked November 2026)
