Insurance for Castalian Springs, Bethpage and Cottontown, TN

Eastern Sumner County households and businesses can request auto, home, life, recreational and business insurance quotes from Mid-South Insurance Agency, a family-owned independent agency at 260 West Main Street in Hendersonville. Cottontown is about 25 minutes from our office, and Castalian Springs and Bethpage are about 30 minutes.

The country east of Gallatin has farms, creeks, historic buildings and a good deal of manufactured housing. These three neighboring communities share a tornado record, and the facts below are worth knowing when you ask for a quote.

An old log farmhouse behind a wooden fence in autumn

Key points

  • Cottontown is about 25 minutes from our Main Street office; Castalian Springs and Bethpage are about 30.
  • NOAA records that the February 5, 2008 EF3 tornado destroyed the Castalian Springs Post Office and 85 homes in Sumner County.
  • About 25.9% of housing in the 37022 ZIP code (Bethpage) is mobile homes (Census).
  • Ask what your policy says about wind and creek flooding before storm season.

The February 2008 tornado

NOAA's Storm Events Database lists an EF3 tornado that began 1.5 miles southwest of Castalian Springs on February 5, 2008. Its narrative states: “The Castalian Springs Post Office was completely destroyed. There were 85 homes destroyed in Sumner County.” NOAA records 7 direct deaths and $10.00 million in damage as estimated at the time.

The same record describes Wynnewood, the historic stagecoach stop in Castalian Springs, losing the top of its structure. NOAA also lists a smaller EF0 tornado at Castalian Springs on January 30, 2013 and another on May 4, 2021. History is not a forecast, and what a policy pays after wind depends on the policy and its deductibles.

Cottontown and the 1998 tornado

On April 3, 1998, NOAA records an F2 tornado from east of Cottontown toward Castalian Springs that downed trees and power lines and took roofs off many homes, with areas just south of Cottontown hardest hit. Hail of 1.75 inches fell at Cottontown that afternoon.

Cottontown is a small community, about 374 residents inside its Census boundary, with a median home value of $441,700 (Census housing profile for Cottontown). The surrounding 37048 ZIP code has about 6,380 residents and about 88.1% owner-occupied homes (Census housing profile for ZIP 37048). Detached garages, workshops and acreage are details to mention when you ask for a quote.

Bethpage and Rock Bridge

Bethpage and the Rock Bridge area share the 37022 ZIP code. The Census Bureau's 2020-2024 survey puts about 25.9% of housing in that ZIP code at mobile homes, with about 90.8% of homes owner-occupied (Census housing profile for ZIP 37022). Percentages are our calculation from Census counts. We quote mobile home policies, and eligibility and terms vary by insurer.

NOAA's entry for the May 2010 flood describes flooding along Bledsoe Creek just northeast of Bethpage near U.S. Highway 31 East and Old Wolf Hill Road, with numerous homes and businesses damaged across the county. On May 11, 2016, a flash flood closed or washed out roads in Bethpage, including Rock Bridge Road and Rock Springs Road.

Water on the roads and the land

A July 7, 2016 NOAA record describes major flash flooding across Sumner County, especially near Cottontown, Bethpage, Hendersonville, Gallatin and Castalian Springs, with homes, vehicles and roads damaged. Homeowners policies generally exclude flood; FloodSmart states that most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage and that flood insurance is a separate policy. Ask us about options for your address. Our guide to flood insurance in Middle Tennessee explains the basics.

Castalian Springs by the numbers

The Census Bureau counts 678 people and 318 housing units inside the Castalian Springs boundary, with a median home built in 1981 and a median value of $283,100 (Census housing profile for Castalian Springs). With a population that small, the margin of error is wide. The 37031 ZIP code covers more ground, with about 3,926 residents and about 11.4% mobile homes (Census housing profile for ZIP 37031).

Annual mileage is one of the details insurers ask about on the auto insurance side. Call 615-824-9009 or text 615-419-5409 and we will compare options from the insurance companies we work with.

Questions from Insurance for Castalian Springs

Do you quote insurance in Castalian Springs, Bethpage and Cottontown?

Yes. Mid-South quotes auto, home, life, recreational and business insurance for these communities and for Rock Bridge, working by phone, text and email.

Does it matter that my home is a mobile or manufactured home?

It can. Eligibility and terms vary by insurer, so we ask about age, foundation and location when we quote.

What did the February 2008 tornado destroy?

NOAA records that the February 5, 2008 EF3 tornado destroyed the Castalian Springs Post Office and 85 homes in Sumner County. What a home policy pays after wind depends on the policy and the insurer.

How far is your office?

Our Hendersonville office is about 25 to 30 minutes away. You do not need to visit, since quotes can be handled by phone, text or email.

More insurance questions and answers

Sources (14)

Request a Free Quote

We do the shopping, you do the saving. Tell us what you would like to insure and we will compare options from the insurance companies we work with, then go over them with you.

Office hours: Monday to Thursday 9:00 am to 4:00 pm, Friday and Saturday 10:00 am to 2:00 pm.

A quote request is not a policy. No coverage is in force until the agency and the insurer confirm it.